BENEFITSMITH
  • Home
  • BenefitSmith Global
    • 2024 Global Benefits Forum
    • IEBA - US Branch
    • 2023 Global Risks & Rewards
    • Elevate Capacity & Well-Being
    • The Future of Talent
  • Insights
  • Self Insured Solutions
  • Where Employers Focus & How Lockton Helps
  • Benchmarking, Trends & Updates
  • Pharmacy Management
  • Data & Analytics
  • People Solutions
  • PE, VC and M&A Support
  • NEEBC & Lockton
  • About BenefitSmith
  • Contact
  • Resources
    • MA Benefit & Leave Mandates
    • Stream with Smith
    • Uncommon Perspectives
    • Lockton Benefit Blog
    • Lockton Employee Benefits
    • Lockton Global Benefits - Compliance News
    • Lockton Insights & Publications
    • Lockton Private Risk Solutions
    • Kaiser Health News
    • New England Employee Benefits Council

Insights

Flipping the PBM Script

8/25/2023

0 Comments

 
Picture
​Blue Shield of CA has a new PBM prescription for their 4.8M members – “flipping that (the current pharmacy supply chain) on its head.” according to CEO Paul Markovich.
 
The health insurer announced a move away from CVS as their PBM and is instead replacing it with multiple partners:
  • CVS – will continue to be the pharmacy dispensing specialty medications
  • Abarca – will be the claim adjudication platform
  • Mark Cuban Cost Plus – will be responsible for the retail pharmacy network development and management
  • Prime Therapeutics – will be responsible for rebates (Prime is part of Ascent GPO with Cigna/Express Scripts)
  • Amazon Pharmacy – will be the mail order pharmacy

In a recent interview with The Wall Street Journal, Blue Shield's CEO, Paul Markovich, highlighted the challenges within the current pharmacy supply chain, characterizing it as a complex and opaque structure designed to maximize profits for its participants. “The current pharmacy supply chain is a forest of opacity and profit,” said Paul Markovich, Blue Shield’s chief executive officer “It is overwhelmingly complex, it is designed to maximize the earnings of the participants.” His company’s new setup, he said, will be “flipping that on its head.”

Blue Shield has unveiled a groundbreaking initiative that aims to bring greater transparency and efficiency to their pharmacy benefit management strategy.

Key highlights of Blue Shield's new setup include:
  1. Diverse Partnership Approach: Blue Shield is diversifying its partners to manage different aspects of their pharmacy benefit management. The new partners include CVS for specialty medications, Abarca for claim adjudication, Mark Cuban Cost Plus for retail pharmacy network development, Prime Therapeutics for rebates, and Amazon Pharmacy for mail-order services.
  2. Transparency and Cost Control: By breaking down the components of their pharmacy benefit management, Blue Shield intends to enhance transparency and provide insights into the cost structure of each part. This strategic move could potentially address the lack of visibility into cost breakdowns that often plague the traditional pharmacy supply chain.
  3. Employer Implications: While this unique model might be challenging to replicate in its entirety for larger organizations, smaller Pharmacy Benefit Managers (PBMs) have been adopting similar approaches. Some employers have found success in outsourcing specific components of their pharmacy benefit management while retaining control over others. This decentralized approach often results in increased transparency and decreased conflicts of interest between the PBM and the plan sponsor.
  4. Industry Watch: While Wall Street analysts are observing this transformation closely, it's yet to be seen if other large organizations will follow suit in the near term. Blue Shield's initiative will likely be scrutinized for its potential to deliver savings and operational efficiency while upending the status quo in the pharmacy supply chain.

Why would Blue CA move this direction?
By breaking apart the components, the new approach can provide more transparency into the cost of each part of the pharmacy benefit. Wall Street analysts don’t believe other large organizations will follow suit in the short term but will be watching closely to see if the new decentralized approach can be executed appropriately and is delivering on the projected savings.
 
What could this mean for employers?
It will be difficult for most employers to replicate this exact model. However, some smaller PBMs have taken the approach to outsource different components themselves. For example, they may own the adjudication platform but outsource the network, rebates, and specialty pharmacy. Some employers like this model as they believe the costs are more transparent and it reduces conflicts of interest between the PBM and the plan sponsor.
 
Lockton Pharmacy Point of View:
We are generally supportive of this approach and have implemented similar structures / components with some health plans clients. By breaking up the sole PBM, there is greater transparency for the cost associated with each component of the pharmacy benefit. Employers can select the best of each vendor to perform these functions. This strategy more likely to be effective for larger, more forward leaning groups. We don't see it working for smaller clients (at least not for right now).
 
Some operational questions
  • Mark Cuban Cost Plus will need to build out a retail network that does not exist today. Currently they only have less than 10K pharmacies set up to take their discount card. Will members have adequate access in CA and nationwide?
  • Will the member experience be impacted by the separation of these components and having to deal with multiple vendors?
  • Will the obligation to pay fees to five vendors offset the drug cost savings that may ensue from more transparency?
 
Adam Fein wrote a great article on this move on his Drug Channels blog "A Reality Check on That Blue Shield of California Announcement"
Picture
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Mike Smith - trying to put my history degree to good use through research and writing .  Mom would be proud but she still wanted me to study business.

    Categories

    All
    Time Off & Leaves

    Archives

    April 2025
    February 2025
    June 2024
    March 2024
    February 2024
    January 2024
    November 2023
    August 2023
    July 2023
    June 2023
    May 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    November 2022
    March 2022
    January 2022
    November 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    September 2020
    May 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020

    Categories

    All
    Time Off & Leaves

    RSS Feed

Copyright 2024 - BenefitSmith.com
Photo from jafsegal (Thanks for the 5 million views)
  • Home
  • BenefitSmith Global
    • 2024 Global Benefits Forum
    • IEBA - US Branch
    • 2023 Global Risks & Rewards
    • Elevate Capacity & Well-Being
    • The Future of Talent
  • Insights
  • Self Insured Solutions
  • Where Employers Focus & How Lockton Helps
  • Benchmarking, Trends & Updates
  • Pharmacy Management
  • Data & Analytics
  • People Solutions
  • PE, VC and M&A Support
  • NEEBC & Lockton
  • About BenefitSmith
  • Contact
  • Resources
    • MA Benefit & Leave Mandates
    • Stream with Smith
    • Uncommon Perspectives
    • Lockton Benefit Blog
    • Lockton Employee Benefits
    • Lockton Global Benefits - Compliance News
    • Lockton Insights & Publications
    • Lockton Private Risk Solutions
    • Kaiser Health News
    • New England Employee Benefits Council